Homestuck was never a good story, just a good encyclopedia of story elements with loose coherent unity.
The art style was always good though, all things considered.
The author's a greedy prick.
The games were bad and should not have been released how they were. The fundraiser was a total scam and I regret having funded it. Audio artist behind the games, James Roach, is a doucher I would not recommend socializing with.
Spinoff paradox space comics during that brief window waiting for the final act, were decent content, wish that had not ended.
The fandom was very average, nothing you couldn't spawn with all existing AI generators and any texts or images from Homestuck, and it will not be missed.
The chanboard is mod-tarded as are the other chanboards related to any topic, and suffer enough censorfucking to warrant not bothering to use any of them regularly or even occasionally.
Tumblr's death was the final nail for this fandom as that was a huge portion of Homestuck's base. These days all Homestuck is is a litmus test for if you know your Internet lore and memes.